Princes of the Apocalypse Review PLUS Converting the Temple of Elemental Evil: T1 – The Village of Hommlet to 5th Edition
First, let’s talk about Princes of the Apocalypse:
I picked up Princes of the Apocalypse a few weeks ago, after we had completed the Hommlet section of Temple of Elemental Evil. In case you weren’t aware, Princes of the Apocalypse is 5th Edition’s campaign for this year, and is not a reboot of the classic module, but derives core ideas and starts a series of entirely new adventures. They’ve done good work in not respawning the old story, but creating a new story with continuity to the old.
The philosophy is that Elemental Evil is something that transcends existence, touching down on various worlds through sheer force of will, infecting different communities with its blight. Ergo, Greyhawk is one of the first places to suffer its wrath, but this time it has found the Forgotten Realms. I can buy that, despite my intense love for Greyhawk .
Fortunately, they have a simple and clever conversion guide showing how to place the new events of the Princes of the Apocalypse in Greyhawk, Eberron, Athas, and other worlds. They translate factions to local entities, making the Harpers equate to the Circle of Eight, the Zhentarim to the Greyhawk Thieves Guild, and so on.
I love the old Temple of Elemental Evil, but as my group stares down the barrel of its 300 room dungeon, I am reminded now that my love is rooted in nostalgia that newer players will likely not appreciate. Accordingly, it is perhaps necessary for a more modern take on game design be applied to a new module. The designers nod to the old module, directing you how to get a copy and advising the ease of conversion (which is somewhat true). I think they have narrowly avoided angering grognards and new players alike by pumping out a spruced up but changed Hommlet and Temple. They’re not imitating the past, they’re building on it, depriving us curmudgeons of an opportunity to bitch about how they messed everything up in the reboot. So, well played, sirs.
Princes of the Apocalypse contains several new regional settings, great maps, and a story that crosses boundaries, suggesting a unifying element to Elemental Evil. The remainder of the book contains items make this a must-have for those converting the old Temple.
First, there are several stat blocks for elemental priests and acolytes. These are kept in a separate section of the book, and are easy to reference. This is going to save you a fair bit of time when going through the various sects, with stats for elemental creatures as well that are completely new, but add nicely to the campaign world. Temple of Elemental Evil suffered from a problem of having somewhat limited options (Monster Manual I) for filling the monster hotel. Choice replacement may spice things up a bit in making your conversion, so I recommend you look at what’s here.
Secondly, Spells, many of which are fairly classic, are found in this book. I did not pick up the Tyranny of the Dragon Queen, and I’m starting to worry that key and classic spells are going to start to appear in the back of numerous $50+ books, pushing players to collect them for just a section of the book. That may be the new way, unless they can be found elsewhere on a legitimate basis. It’s not a good way to collect information, but I anticipate increasing web resources to fill that gap.
Third, Magic items are found in the book with details on several weapons of great power (artifacts) which I am going to place into my game in key places. Other more miscellaneous magic items also exist, fleshing out the DMG’s selection and providing thematically entertaining tools that keep the mystery of magic items alive.
For those reasons, I would recommend checking it out. It’s good in it’s own right, and is a truly epic campaign (taking the players up to 15th level). I think that you’ll want to have it if you’re doing the old Temple, and see what you want to bring to it or change.
CONVERTING T1- THE VILLAGE OF HOMMLET
We’ve just finished this part of the module, so I can place the conversion material here now. NOTE THERE ARE SPOILERS AHEAD so anyone getting ready to play the old T1: Village of Hommlet should stop reading now. Below are a complete list of monsters found in the Moathouse and their page number in the Monster Manual. Some are quite obvious, but others not so much. I found these to most closely match the original intention and play of the first mod, and the challenge seemed spot-on.
- Brigands p. 343
- Bugbear p. 33
- Crayfish, Giant = (as Giant Scorpion p. 327 but no sting attack)
- Frogs, Giant (Large) = Giant Toad p.329
- Frogs, Giant (Small) = Giant Frogs 325
- Ghouls p.148
- Gnoll p.163
- Green Slime DMG p.105 (it’s a hazard now)
- Guardsman = Guard p.347
- Lareth the Beautiful = See below
- Leader = Berserker p.344
- Lieutenant = Bandit Captain p. 344
- Lizard, Giant = p.326 but add 2 to AC because of magic shield in its belly. Stupid, but true to form.
- Ogre p.237
- Rats, Giant p. 327
- Sergeant = Thug p.350
- Snake, Giant p327
- Spider, Huge p.328
- Tick, Giant = See below
- Zombie p 316
Medium Beast, unaligned
AC 16, HP 22, Speed: 20′ Climb 20′
Str 14 Dex 8 Con 16 Int 2 Wis 8 Cha 6
Senses: Darkvision 60ft , Passive Perception 9
Languages — None
Challenge 1/4 (50XP)
SA: Blood Drain Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft, one reature. Hit: 1d6+2 piercing damage, and attaches to target. While attached, Giant Tick doesn’t attack, each round target loses 1d6+2 for bloodloss.
Giant Tick can detach itself by spending 5 feet of its movement. Drops off after draining 15 hp. DC 14 Str check to remove)
Lareth the Beautiful
Medium Humanoid (Drow Elf)
Level 5 Cleric – Proficiency bonus +3
AC 21 HP 55 Speed: 25′
Senses: Darkvision 120′
Special Abilities – Sunlight Sensitivity, Channel Divinity (Trickery), Divine Spellcasting, Blessing of the Trickster, Invoke Duplicity
Str 18 (Save +4)
Dex 17 (Save +3)
Con 16 (Save +3)
Int 14 (Save +2)
Wis 18 (Save +7)
Chr 18 (Save +7)
Skills: Deception +7, Insight +7, Persuasion +7, Sleight of Hand +6
Abilities: Dancing Lights 1/day; Darkness 1/day
Staff of Striking [DMG p. 203] (+10 to hit, 1d6+7 plus 1d6 per charge expended)
Inventory – Plate Mail +1, Shield, Staff of Striking, Silver Holy Symbol, etc
Spells (DC 15)
Cantrips – Guidance, Resistance, Sacred Flame, Thaumaturgy,
Level 1 –Bane, Charm person, Disguise Self, Healing Word, Inflict Wounds
Level 2 – Blindness, Hold Person, Silence
Level 3 –Animate Dead, Bestow Curse, Mirror Image, Pass without trace