Generators or Degenerators? The Mixed Blessing of Character Generator Culture

February 23, 2015 3 comments

cease and desist!Guest Post by Matt Orbach

Recently, Pathguy got a letter from WOTC, politely asking that he remove his 5E character generator and any other content that might be their IP. I’m not going to discuss that choice here; what WOTC did was legal, and there are boards aplenty debating the matter. Suffice it to say that what you can do legally and what you can do wisely do not always coincide.

But it put to the question, do these generators really help the game, or do they remove us too far from the fundamentals? As it happened, I hadn’t visited this page in quite a while, but I was reminded of it as a tool to help level a 5E character.

Pathguy’s generator was a great tool. When I found it was unavailable, I was forced to level up by hand. As it turned out, leveling by hand was very easy for 5E, although this is not always the case for all rules systems. It caused me to wonder how reliance on character generators for popular systems had shaped the quality of play from a GM perspective and from a player perspective.

THE GM PERSPECTIVE
As a GM, I come to a game with a set of expectations as to what my players will do during a session, including, but not limited to:
• know most of the rules, and ask questions about the others
• learn how characters and the game world interact
• pay attention
• enjoy the narrative of the story-line
• act out characters
• collaborate with the other players
• have fun

I’ve also come to understand that a group of committed players enjoying themselves will typically do about 75% of these; which is fine, as long as “have fun” is somewhere in there. It might be great for everyone to come prepared with a carefullly researched and crafted character, and it probably makes for a richer, deeper game, but realistically it just won’t always happen.

To enjoy a game a player has to have an understanding of what they are doing. A character generator that removes that understanding inhibits enjoyment of the game by making the character mechanically incomprehensible for most play systems. A good build is useless without some knowledge of its implications, and inhibits having fun if it is mysterious and incomprehensible to the player.

THE PLAYER PERSPECTIVE
As a player, I have slightly different expectations. I know the groups I’ve played with all seem to enjoy different aspects of the game. These can be primarily broken into two groups:

The Artist
This player enjoys creating interesting characters, sometimes with unexpected traits. Some temper this so the character can be effective in the game world, and thus more involved in the story. For others, the reverse seems to be true: they start from a fairly blank slate and draw out the character from the actions taken during gameplay, laboring only to create one who will take effective actions. Still others go further to extremes, creating bizarre and often unplayable characters.

The Engineer
There may very well be a graphing calculator or spreadsheet involved, because these folks enjoy the mathematical permutations and precise calculations of creating a character that is purpose-built. While personality and story is a factor, it is secondary to the build mechanic.

I fall primarily into the first category myself. There’s a certain appeal, I’ll admit, to the Engineer, but I lost my love for that sort of endeavor years ago. You see, I spent a summer designing mecha upon mecha for a tabletop wargame called Battletech. But when the hour of completion neared, I began to realize that the GM had no intention of actually playing the simulation as a massive dropship game, sure to be a fight of epic proportions…oh, the glory that was not! He simply enjoyed, and assumed his players enjoyed, crafting the pieces. Even with the computers of the time (early 90’s) we could have done it faster, but we would have missed fretting over the small decisions of armor vs. weight v.s ammo capacity.

Engineers enjoy the thrill of the build. Artists want to tell a story (efficacy coming in a distant second).

THE APPLICATION

Character Generators can facilitate quick and effective ends for the needs of both these player personalities as well as accommodating the needs and desires of the GM perspective, but only when used judiciously.

Here’s what I think Pathguy did right: his character generator was fluid and helpful, and allowed you to “see” the rules as you went through the build process. It didn’t mask them or create copy pasta out of inputs, but walked you through the relevant choices and bypassed rules not related, but still allowed you to glance at them as you scrolled down. It encourages the player to consult the related rules and sourcebooks, rather than depend on an output charsheet note.

A character generator needs to facilitate rather than inhibit an understanding of the rules; a helping hand rather than a crutch.

There are more generators out there that fall into the crutch category than don’t, however. A very quick search will lead you to whole-cloth character generators, with everything from family relationships, to appearance, to complete backstory. And if you’re stuck, those can help… but if you aren’t interested enough to create something, will you play it? A “disgruntled, fine boned young man with a bad arm who is from the sea and lives with an army of undead” doesn’t think you will. Thanks http://whothefuckismydndcharacter.com/

“Artist” and “Engineer” must perform a balanced calculation to make a really good gaming experience, and GM’s and players must work together to really optimize the outcome. And the right generator is only one of many tools that helps the player and GM get there.

Matt Orbach is a raconteur, an alchemist, a some-time magician and a noted character creator. He should always play a bard.

Star Wars: Lords of Nal Hutta Review

February 15, 2015 1 comment

SWE11_book_leftThe Lords of Nal Hutta sourcebook for Hutt Space just came out for Star Wars: Edge of the Empire RPG. I’ve been eagerly anticipating this release, as one of the groups I play Star Wars with has repeatedly crossed the Hutts from the Beginner Box and the extension of that called The Long Arm of the Hutt, as well as their most recent adventures on Cloud City in Jewel of Yavin. It only seems fitting that the campaign ends with taking the fight straight to the heart of Hutt space on Nar Shadaa, or maybe even a throne world.

The first thing I noticed about this book was it’s heft. It felt a lot heavier than the typical profession sourcebooks, and sure enough, it weighs in at 144 pages compared to 96 for the professions. The only other sector sourcebook is Suns of Fortune for the Corellian sector, which follows the exact same format. Four sections: History and background information, hyperspace maps and notable planets, new player options with new races and equipment, and finally modular encounters that the GM can drop in based on location. Some of the encounters are single scenes, others would be long enough for an entire session or two.

To this day, Suns of Fortune is the Edge book I’ve used the least. I think this is for a variety of reasons. The new races and player options were not all that compelling with Selonians, Dralls, and Corellian Humans. With Corellia and the surrounding worlds being squarely in the Core Worlds, it didn’t seem to match what I feel is the aesthetic of *EDGE* of the Empire. Granted, Edge doesn’t have to be geographical as much as being on the fringes of established society, but to me it seems more true to form scratching out shady living on the notorious gangster moon of Nar Shadaa than it does racing or gambling on Corellia.

SWE11-speciesLords of Nal Hutta has likely benefited from years of development for the system. While it follows the exact same structure as Suns, both the player options and modular encounters are way more compelling.

First off, let’s take a look at new races: Sakiyans, Niktos, Ganks, and Hutts. Yes, you can play as a Hutt. Sakiyans are lithe, intelligent hunters and trackers, and their homeworld is the home of the Assassin’s Guild. Niktos come in five different flavors: Red (desert), Green (forest), Mountain (Bluish-grey), Pale (ocean), and Southern. All have different special abilities based on the area they are from. Reds start with a rank in Resilience, Greens with Coordination, Mountains with Survival, and so forth. Ganks start with cybernetic enhancements, and while wookiepedia doesn’t back me up, it seems like General Grievous is a Gank. Militaristic and warlike, they often collect trophies from their victims, more cybernetics means greater prestige, they are always clad head to toe in high-tech battle armor. Sound like anyone from the movies? All of these options are interesting in their own way. I don’t think I would choose to play a Hutt myself, but it’s interesting that it’s an option. Just the options presented here would make an awesome gang.

SWE11-WheetaPalaceThe modular encounters include a game of cat and mouse with Space Pirates, searching for spice-producing mushrooms on Toydaria, a marketplace shootout, a Hutt dinner turned gladiator match (of course), and finally a treasure hunt on a Hutt throne world. So much awesome adventure awaits!

This book is fantastic, filled with awesome history and backstory of Hutts, their clans and Kajidics, as well as great player options and adventure seeds. If you like the central themes of Edge of the Empire, this book will not disappoint!

Back to the Classics: Returning to the Temple of Elemental Evil

February 8, 2015 6 comments

The Temple

When I realized the 5th Edition was built with a mind to accommodate classic concepts, I started thinking what I do when any edition of D&D comes out…. TEMPLE OF ELEMENTAL EVIL.

I love this module, LOVE IT.  When I was a kid I played it three times, read it cover to cover, and played it a few more times over the intervening years. I ran it for a group in college, and some variation of those characters and that group for 15 years.  It, like the other classics of D&D (Slave Lords, Giants, and Demonweb Pits, to  name a few) are amazing, iconic stories that are world defining.  When I realized that quite a number of our local grognards had somehow missed the opportunity to play this classic, I knew it was time to see what 5th Edition Temple looked like.

Conversion to a new system is always a crap shoot.  There is always a temptation to convert straight over from the original, without considering the change in difficulty from older editions of the game to the new.  Right now I’m in the early conversion stages (having converted over the Village of Homlett) with a tentative readiness to recalibrate everything after the first TPK. The problem for me is that 5th Edition is so new, and my experience with it so limited (Beginner Box and a couple of Adventurer’s League mods) that am not sure how powerful I can anticipate the players will be.  I know that in the Beginner Box, they took on and defeated a monster or two that I would never have thought possible at that level in any other edition.  5th Edition has a way of letting half the party get knocked to negatives in any combat but suddenly be all up and triumphant by the end.  It’s really confusing to plan around for a conversion and CR’s seem almost irrelevant.  So far, I’m doing a straight conversion to what’s in the monster manual and waiting to see what happens.  I anticipate things are going to become unhinged when they walk into their first room full of bugbears, as apparently 5E thinks very highly of bugbears.  Very highly.  But Temple was tough, and characters died. And that’s something that’s been missing from games for me lately… I’m a little worried death won’t even be a concern in 5th edition, but the Temple always seems to come through in that department, so for now I’m relaxing and seeing what happens.

There are a number of encounters that I look forward to running that genuinely kicked the crap out of my characters every time we went through them, and I’m sure the first encounter most people remember from this series is the most deadly.  I remember our cleric casting his two healing spells and limping back to town and sleeping for three days . Strange though it may sound, it’s exactly that kind of experience I want my players to have…  Not the hopeless slaughter but the challenge and the peril and the overcoming of incredible obstacles.  I want them to never think about a giant tick as being something to sneeze at.  I want them to start carving up the bellies of each monster they find in the hope that there is hidden loot inside.  I want the citizens of Homlett to come alive and become single name icons for a type of character or personality trait (‘Stop being such an Elmo’). Some of the oddball characters that can rise to the fore in a game like this can be surprising.  A few bad guys became good guys in our campaign, and a few good guys became bad guys in others.  Some nobodies became demi-gods (Gwyneth Lilburne, the Silver Stitch; Black Jay, the Patron Saint of Gnollish worship of St. Cuthbert….. yeah, that). I want it to breathe for them the way it breathes for me.

The thing about Temple of Elemental Evil is it is largely a sandbox.  After playing Paizo’s adventure paths for years, it’s refreshing to play a sandbox game where you can really open up options to the players.  I was surprised and amused when one player expressed slight concern that it was ‘too sandboxy’.  I was puzzled that it could be a downside, but I think that kind of freedom can be a little daunting when you’re not used to it.  I think after getting  a taste of it, people are going to wonder why they ever did it any other way.

However, I will say that I have a few fears and reservations.  Going back over the module and reading the campy box text about seeking fame and fortune, I noticed that a lot of the memories that were in this mod were placed there by great GM’s and great players.  Many towns folk are just named ‘Farmer’ and ‘Wainright’.  Much of the rich story has been added in my brain, and the justifications elaborated on to the point where memory greatly surpasses the actual published text.  What if you can’t go home again? What if you can’t go back to Homlett? There’s a legitimate fear there, that maybe this module doesn’t stand up to the test of time, that others might not appreciate it for what it is.  Maybe my low standards and youthful enthusiasm made up for a lot of shortcomings that my older self won’t enjoy.  My feeling is it will prove itself, but there is that fear.

The Good Ol’ Moathouse

Wizard’s announcement that the Temple of Elemental Evil was going to be a feature of this season’s campaign theme strikes me both as a sign of the merits of this series and also as a maybe an unwelcome travelling companion on this journey.  If they redo it, what will it be like?  Will it distract from, enhance, mitigate or overdevelop elements of my story, the old module, the known universe?  Will it be set in my beloved Greyhawk? What will it do?

Temple has been a known quantity for over 20 years.  Changing the mythos tempts fate.  Maybe they do it right, maybe not.  My understanding is that the new material is different than the Temple itelf  Maybe that falls in line… complimenting, not changing.

While this blog post is about the why of starting up Temple, future ones will be the how.  Look back for conversion tips from the Village of Homlett under the category Elemental Evil.  I’d post more now but Wednesday, we head for the Moathouse!

Hard-Core Crypt of the Everflame

February 6, 2015 Comments off

Last night several of us played the module Crypt of the Everflame as part of the new Core Campaign mode of Pathfinder Society Organized Play. Here’s a summary of what happened (without spoilers) and what I thought of it all.

The Party Members:

Summary:

All the party members were newly-minted 1st level characters without a scenario under their belt. Four players have played extensively in Pathfinder Society and one is relatively new to the Pathfinder Role-Playing Game itself. Having played this module before, I knew what to expect but I did not give away any hints or anything for the others that had not.

We were extremely deficient in the healing arts and had an extended stay (2-3 days) in the crypt after just barely setting foot inside. We used the Treat Deadly Wounds section of the Heal skill; something I have never even thought, or had, to use before. The sorcerer had a Healing Kit and used it quite effectively.

The fighters smashed through everything they were able to connect with (player cold dice) and the rogue dealt admirable damage with his falchion/sneak attack combo. Unfortunately, that usually put him in the sight of the enemies and he took the punishment accordingly (GM hot dice). Besides being the primary healer, the sorcerer plugged away with burning hands and magic missiles.

As the cleric, I spent most of my time trying out the different abilities of this cleric build (negative channel, hand of the acolyte, burning hands, fire-bolt and command undead) to see what worked and what did not. It was neat to be able to take control of skeletons and turn them against their buddies and having my heavy mace fly from my hand to strike an enemy was thematically cool.

I will say that we had fun with the role-playing aspect of this session. The fighters played to their weaknesses (low intelligence) with the sorcerer providing encouragement to them while the half-orcs had to overcome some racial bias from villagers. The cleric found past contracts between Asmodeus and the undead that allowed him to command them so easily.

Conclusion:

At lower levels the Core Campaign is tougher without all of the extra options that players take for granted, especially if your party is not balanced regarding classes. As characters advance in level, they will need to diversify their abilities and equipment as best they can but will definitely learn to lean more heavily on other members of the party for support. I feel this will take Pathfinder Society Organized Play in a slightly different direction as heroics will become group stories instead of individual derring-do. The learning curve will be steep and may cost many Pathfinder agents their lives, but it will be worth it in the end.

Read last week’s Article about the Core Campaign.

Categories: Uncategorized

Pathfinder Society Core Campaign

January 29, 2015 1 comment

With the announcement of the new Core Campaign option for Paizo’s Pathfinder Society Organized Play comes a new way to play. The Core Campaign only allows the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Core Rulebook, the Character Traits Web Enhancement, and the Guide to Pathfinder Organized Play. This is a perfect opportunity for new players to jump in on the fun and learn the game without being overwhelmed with all of the different options and tricked-out characters of current players. It is also an opportunity for veteran players to take the challenge to create characters with less mechanical fluff and play characters with more role-playing substance.

It seems like they have taken a page from Fifth Edition Dungeons and Dragons to create a sort of ‘Pathfinder Simplified’ where it is still Pathfinder, but on a much more simplified scale. But the advantage that Pathfinder has over D&D 5th Edition is the amount of original, quality adventures available to play. Granted the veteran players have played a large number of these adventures, but returning to them in the Core Campaign will have a decidedly different feel of play, especially if they are played from the beginning and in order (not randomly).

Now to present the Core Campaign Pregens (what you really came for). The challenge was to create characters that could still rock and not have a watered-down or too simple of a feel. The results came out better than expected; an archer, an undead controlling, fire-slinging cleric, a dwarven berserker, a gnomish sorcerer-wizard, a beautiful noblewoman paladin, and a slippery half-orc rogue with a big sword. Each character has a little gold left over to purchase traveling gear (backpacks, pouches, etc.) as a player deems appropriate. And you can always change the sex, ethnicity, etc. to fit your play style. Have fun!

Click on their name to view their character sheet:

Vrandall Greenleaf (Human Fighter)

Tall and thin, Vrandall has left the forests and his home of Falcon’s Hollow for the bustling city of Absalom and the Pathfinder Society. Known as one of the best young archers of any militia in Andoran, he has pledged bow and sword to Major Colson Maldris, a fellow countryman, to preserve freedom and expose corruption throughout the region.

Notes: Vrandall can deal damage, plain and simple. With Point Blank Shot, Rapid Shot and Deadly Aim at 1st level, he is the quintessential archer. As he advances in levels, he should take feats and equipment that enhance his capabilities. The first order of business would be to purchase a composite longbow (Str +2) to take advantage of his strength.

Claudiss of Egorian (Human Cleric)

Dressed in red and black robes draped over his armor and tapping the heavy mace on his belt, the glib-tongued young barrister Claudiss is an expert at crafting contracts. Hailing from Egorian in Cheliax, he calls on the fires of Hell to execute the contracts made by undead creatures and turn them to Asmodeus’ service. He has heard of the vast vaults of magical items held by the Pathfinder Society and joined them for the chance to research the magics of Golarion.

Notes: Claudiss is an interesting build for a cleric. He channels negative energy, throws fire bolts and his mace and commands undead. He has decent damage dealing capabilities in melee and at range and is tough enough to handle several roles in a party. He may not be able to channel energy to heal in a pinch, but he can perform those duties outside combat with ease.

Durn Trueaxe (Dwarf Barbarian)

One of the toughest dwarves he knows, Durn is a warrior at heart. He learned early to channel his anger into the swing of his waraxe and crush evil under the heel of his boots. Originally joining the Pathfinder Society as hired muscle, he decided to stay on as the temptation to adventure had overtaken him.

Notes: Durn is tough. He is a decent damage dealer with a good Armor Class, but his hit points set him apart. You could alter him to be a human (Bonus Feat = Toughness; 20 hit points at level 1) or half-orc, but dwarves need some barbarian action every so often. You could also lose the waraxe and shield to wield a greataxe or greatsword for more damage, but you lower his Armor Class considerably (especially when raging).

Zerkesite and Wart (Gnome Sorcerer and Toad)

Always too exciteable to sit down and learn wizardry, Zerkesite found that he was a gifted natural and was able to do many of the things his wizard friends had to study so hard to accomplish. He is a curious young gnome with a thirst for knowledge that has led him (and his faithful toad, Wart) to the Grand Lodge of the Pathfinder Society in Absalom.

Notes: To keep the wizard role in this party somewhat simple and without some of the technical parts of the wizard class, he is actually a sorcerer with the Arcane bloodline. He may have less spells, but he is more flexible and that will help newer players until they get used to the game.

Tenisha Reacklin (Half-Elf Paladin)

The beautiful red-headed Tenisha of the noble Reacklin family in Absalom heard the calling of Shelyn early in life. After observing some of the more destitute and unsavory conditions in the city, her temperment led her to take on a more militant stance in expousing her faith to become a paladin.

Notes: This may be an interesting one to play. She’s a noble, interested in pretty things, and used to the good life. Yet, she has a hot-head and wants to help those in need. There are plenty of role-playing opportunities here. She has a reach weapon (Shelyn’s favored weapon; a glaive) and a high Charisma. As she levels and gains more paladin abilities, she will be quite the thorn in a GM’s side.

Haddock the Sly (Half-Orc Rogue)

Once an enforcer and security for several Qadiran trade princes, Haddock had had enough of the ‘nothing-but-a-dumb-orc’ attitude towards him. Still large and intimidating with this trusty falchion, he realized that he had to carve his own fortune out of Golarion. Seeking the knowledge he needed, he joined the Pathfinder Society with a new purpose.

Notes: Half-orcs are always the bruisers of the party, but Haddock is more. He is still strong and can deal damage with a high-crit weapon (a falchion; a racial weapon) and sneak attack. Taking Power Attack as soon as possible would add to that damage considerably. He is also tough and has the other abilities of a rogue (trap-finding, disable device).

 

Hull Breach!!!! Sci-Fi Card Game Takes No Prisoners!

January 26, 2015 1 comment

2015-01-25 21.46.46I went to SCARAB  last week, and was able to play a round of the Living Card Game “Hull Breach” by NSB Games, Inc (‘Not So Broken‘ in case you were wondering).  Grognard that I am, it took me a long time to get accept the idea of playing a card game, thinking that it bore too much proximity to Magic the Gathering for my taste.  However, I’ve started to enjoy a number of what folks call “Living Card Games” which are not collectible.  While expansions may be available in a living card game, they are fixed expansions with predetermined cards, and are available to anyone equally without the need to buy numerous ‘boosters’.  I’m explaining this here because some people may not give a card game a chance for fear of that element of many games we are aware of.

Hull Breach was run for me by a fun husband-wife team at SCARAB after showing up too late for my preregistered slot.  I love picking up a new thing at a Con, as I mentioned months ago in my previous article, and the idea of things blowing up in space was too attractive to not try for my slot of dead time.  Hull Breach did not disappoint.

The Setting is rich, which is the game’s strongest asset.  25th Century, space is the new war ground of the corporations vying for dominance in interstellar trade.  Xeros Orbital Shipyards, Anaheim Manufacturing, and Bank of the Galaxy are the three corps that come in “Corporate Wars”, a full game.  The other box set, Loyalty and Vigilance, houses three additional factions, which I would summarize as the Brown Coats, the Imperial Navy, and the Galactic IRS.  I’ll let you know what they are really called when I pick up that set, but that’s the long and short of it.

The Cards in this game are well laid out, with everything available at a glance in a very intuitive way.  Costs or assets are color coded with up and down arrows reflecting their cost or production value.  A series of icons along the bottom of each card that are generally very uniform show you the firepower and armor of each unit, along with the unit’s carrying capacity if it is capable of housing marines, ships or drones.

2015-01-25 21.51.51Game play begins with a setting up phase where each faction builds their space station and defenses.  Each faction manufactures resources at differing rates, and station additions can add to that total.  Initial ships are deployed and minimal defenses erected, and play begins.

The strategy in Hull Breach is to build your forces up for an epic onslaught during the Engagement phase.  Multiplayer games may differ, but in a two player game, it would seem that throwing everything at the enemy is a fairly sound strategy as combat continues until one side or the other is defeated or withdraws.  In a multi-player game, leaving some ships at home becomes a bit more of a necessity, as the other players can take advantage of your recent struggles to set upon your unprotected base.

Combat, once engaged, is resolved by rolling multiple d10’s with a target number based on the defender’s armor rating, plus any special abilities.  After a successful assault, enemy ships can be boarded for marine v. marine combat, and the ship commandeered.  That occupied ship has the potential to revert back to enemy hands if you are foolish enough to remove your garrison (or if it is unfortunate enough to be killed in the line of duty).  The end result of the boarding action, however, is a snowball effect as ships turn to your side in the war against the enemy faction.

CRITICAL REVIEW

I had a lot of fun with Hull Breach, and picked up a copy.  The retail price tag is a little hefty at just over $35.00, but the production value is pretty high (see the photos of the interior).  Each box comes with a book of short fiction, three decks of cards, 10d10, two bags of tokens, and a small well bound little rulebook.

Game play is interesting, fast moving, and allows for enough strategy to make things fun without slowing down overall play.  Many cards in the game allow you to search through your deck often, which certainly is fine, but eliminates some elements of luck of the draw, which may appeal to some and less to others, and can take time.  If you’re unfamiliar with the game and the cards in your deck, it will require more time to play, but I think we finished our two player game in 20 minutes (with a win for me, by the way), so it was far from burdensome.  Discovering it was one of the highlights of the convention, for me.

Living Card games draw the most value from deck building, and NSB Games plans on supporting the game with additional expansions.  While corporate cards are color coded to be separate from non-corporate cards, I would like to see additional expansions be unique to various factions to help to refine the flavor of that particular faction.  In living card games like Fantasy Flight’s Netrunner, factions have to build from their own decks, but may use other cards on a limited basis through the use of influence, creating a very specific world feel and play style that is closely tied to the faction itself.  Hull Breach, I feel, could benefit from the same time of restrictions, or perhaps by tying the advantage of each card to the faction playing it.  I think think the author’s of the Hull Breach setting are proud of what they’ve put together, and they should be.  as the factions really appealed to me. Building on that is the way to go as more products go forward.  Hull Breach is a fun, fast, easy to play game that has great potential.  Keep an eye on this one, and see if your FLGS can’t get you a copy.  You’ll be glad you did.

Categories: Adventure, Card, Games, Reviews

Dungeon Master’s Screen Review

January 19, 2015 2 comments

IMG_0006I wanted to be just as impressed with this screen as I have been with the DMG and PHB, but it turns out 5e is not on a consistent hit streak like Fantasy Flight. This was a bit of a missed opportunity. A good DM screen can kickstart imagination, as well as being a useful reference for charts so we spend less time digging in books.

Let’s get to the good stuff, first. The horizontal format is excellent. This allows the DM to section off one end of the table with plenty of real estate for maps, notes, books, modules, dice and whatever else, while still being able to see the players and the map (if you use one). It also provides for the awesome panoramic artwork of an iconic dragon battle, with about every major PC archetype represented. Interesingly, 4 out of 5 are ladies, but there is not a lot of variety in skin-tone. The kobold minions rushing in to the fray make it one cohesive battle, unlike previous screens that try to cram a ton of monsters or battles on to one screen. On the informational side of the screen, the conditions are front and center, which is very helpful. Just to the right are other helpful little charts like cover, light, setting DCs, and what skills are associated with what abilities.

IMG_0002On to the not so good. There is quite a bit of wasted space, and strange chart selection. My first thought was that maybe 5e just doesn’t have as many arcane charts as older editions. But as I review both the PHB and more importantly the DMG, that really isn’t the case. The far left panel is dedicated to NPC creation, which, while somewhat helpful, is not something I would generally refer to on the fly. Included is a random name generator, which is my favorite chart on the panel. Even this seems incomplete, however. The chart is d20 if you want to randomize, and has a beginning, middle, and end of a name. However the beginning is missing 4 entries, and the ending is missing 1. There are 26 letters in the alphabet, I know there aren’t going to be a lot of names that start of X or Z but why leave out C and G? Just C alone you could add Co-, Ca-, Chi- as beginnings; pretty much inexcusable.

IMG_0004The far right panel has some other odd choices. Travel pace chart maybe useful, but encounter distance depending on terrain? Is that a thing? Also there is a chart called Damage by Level and Severity which from the numbers looks like it refers to traps, but doesn’t really specify. Then we get down to the REALLY questionable choices: tables called Something Happens! and Quick Finds. Not only do they have nothing to do with the mechanics of 5e, the choices are uninspired and pretty much useless. 18 on something happens is “The sun comes out.” 11 is “Someone gets angry.” Really? Quick finds includes such gems as 3 “Food or Drink.” and 9 “Monster Parts.” What does that even mean?! The last third of it is repeated Tarrasque art from the DMG.

IMG_0005Ok, so some very odd choices were made, what would be better? It would be one thing if this game just didn’t have any charts that would be helpful on a screen, or they were too lengthy too include in a reasonable amount of space. There are a ton of charts I would have included instead. The criteria for this would be that the chart exists in the DMG or PHB, and is small, but helpful, and kind of obscure to look up like: Salable Magic Items, and Selling a Magic Item (p. 130 DMG), Potion Miscibility and Scroll Mishaps (p. 140 DMG), Saving Throws (p.238 DMG), conversation reactions (p.245), Object AC and HP (p.246-247 DMG), and Improvising Damage (p.249 DMG). There are many more.

Final rant: the cover of the screen is a poster for Adventurer’s League. In itself, that is okay, but it uses the Acererak art from the cover of the DMG and just says We Want YOU at your nearest game store. It seems to almost be a reference to Uncle Sam recruitment posters with it’s red, white and blue border, but then just has DungeonsandDragons.com at the bottom. Wht not dnd.wizards.com/playevents/organized-play or a URL to the store locator? It just seems like more wasted space. That being said, AL does need DMs, and how DM experience is handled when you run AL is a whole other blog post.

The worst part is, a lot of the heavy lifting was already done by Lance Larsen. Before the DMG was even out, he compiled some of the more confusing concepts and things looked up most often in to one handy sheet. If you haven’t downloaded it already, I would highly suggest it. Conclusion: you should probably make your own screen. The art for this one is great, but the substance is not.

Categories: 5e, Books, DnD, Reviews, RPGs, Tips
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 473 other followers